You scream, I scream, we all scream for ice cream! And why not? When it comes to a hot summer day, there is no better way to cool off then stopping by any one of these North Shore establishments to indulge yourself. But who am I kidding, it doesn’t matter if it’s the middle of Winter, I am always up for ice cream!
Check out the list of North Shore ice cream, gelato and custard shops below (national chains not included). Please let us know if we missed any!
Hartigan's Ice Cream Shoppe
2909 Central St., 847-491-1232
From Ice Cream to hot dogs and everything in between, Hartigan's Ice Cream Shoppe has something for everyone! Hartigan's has more than 50 flavors including soft-serve yogurt and sherbets too, plus ice cream cakes, a bakery case, coffee bar and a full soda fountain menu.
Andy's Frozen Custard
719 Church St., 847-864-8009
Serving frozen custard sundaes, concretes & more, plus a choice of toppings (with a drive-thru window).
517 Dempster St., 847-868-8767
FRÍO Gelato® is proud to artfully bring Argentina’s gelato tradition to the U.S., offering consumers a natural, healthy, and unique dessert. FRÍO Gelato® is made in an allergen-friendly kitchen with a nut and gluten-free focus. No artificial flavorings are added — only fresh and natural ingredients. 100% homemade.
2012 Central St., 847-475-1381
Bright and cheery community spot for great coffee, pastries and Evanston-based FRÍO Gelato®.
Homer's Homemade Gourmet Ice Cream
1237 Green Bay Rd., 847-251-0477
A North Shore favorite since 1935, Homer's continues to do ice-cream the old-fashioned way: thick, heavy, and so very delicious. 40+ flavors to choose from, plus sorbets, sherbets and frozen yogurt.
Glenview Dairy Bar
1015 Harlem Ave, Glenview, 847-724-2029
Serving delicious soft-service ice cream to the North Shore communities since 1955! Old school establishment with outdoor seating only. Known for their quick service and huge selection of dipped and dried toppings. Open from April – October. Cash only.
Graeter’s Ice Cream
1347 Shermer Rd., 847-513-6540
Graeter's has created small batch, french pot ice cream for over 147 years, featuring 30+ flavors including its most popular, Black Raspberry Chip. Not just chips, but rather chocolate chunks that melt in your mouth. shop also features chocolates and other sweet gift items.
733 St. John's Ave., 847-433-0430
Baker Boys is a true "mom and pop" dessert shop owned and operated by long-time pals Pastry Chef Jordan Rappaport and Peter Rauser. In addition to delicious cupcakes and other sweet treats, they make and spin nine different frozen custards and sorbets daily.
ArrivaDolce Gelato and Coffee Bar
1823 St. John's Ave., 847-433-3103
Artisan gelato, locally roasted coffee, homemade baked goods, soup and light lunch fare in a comfy rustic Italian setting. The only con, they close at 4:30 pm (2 pm on Sundays).
617 Central Ave, Highland Park, 847-432-2233
38 flavors of gelato and sorbet are made on site and served fresh daily. We also make milkshakes, root beer floats, sorbettinis and a variety of coffee drinks.
Get The Scoop
841 N. Waukegan Rd., 847-945-6613
Simple, little ice cream shop attached to the infamous Deer Franks, featuring, ice cream, frozen yogurt and other sweets and treats,
Sweet Pea's Ice Cream
764 Sheridan Rd., 847-266-1116
A wonderful neighborhood ice cream parlor featuring super-premium fountain treats and signature chocolate-dipped frozen bananas. The ice cream comes from The Chocolate Shoppe, a family-owned dairy in Madison, Wisconsin.
La Michoacana Ice Cream Parlor
2641 Waukegan Ave., border of Highwood/Highland Park, 847-579-9095
Don’t let the shared space with the local currency exchange front fool you. This quaint, family owned and operated ice cream parlor serves up the real deal. Just look for the big colorful ice cream cone out front and soon you’ll be savoring Mexican-inspired ice cream and homemade popsicles made with all natural ingredients plus unique flavors that you won’t find anywhere else.
260 E. Deerpath Rd.,847-295-1111
Beyond the delicious ice cream and old fashion soda fountain, Sweet’s offers a full array of chocolates, nuts, toffee, caramel and chocolate apples, brittle and so much more.
270 Market Square, 847-283-9500
Cute candy, ice cream and frozen yogurt shop, featuring tons of nostalgic and novelty treats.
Check out the Best of the North Shore:
Our favorite restaurants, stores and service providers all in one place!
We are a top team of real estate agents specializing in the lakefront communities of Evanston, Wilmette, Winnetka, Kenilworth, Northfield, Glencoe, Highland Park and surrounding areas.
If you would like to schedule a buyer or seller consultation with the Come Home North Shore Team, please give us a call at 847.881.6657 or send us a note here.